Skip to main content

Honeycomb Strategy

How to Improve Your Loyalty Program: Lessons From Australia’s Top Program, Flybuys

Flybuys won because it made loyalty effortless. Here is how it did it, and how your brand can do the same.

Flybuys has been crowned the top retail program in our Science of Loyalty 2026 study. We judged programs on three criteria: membership rate, active engagement and impact on spend.

Flybuys had the highest membership rate of any program. But that’s not why it won.

Bar chart of Australia's top 10 retail loyalty programs by index score, led by Flybuys, then Everyday Rewards and MyMacca's Rewards.
Bar chart of loyalty program membership rates across Australian adults, with Flybuys highest, then Everyday Rewards and Qantas Frequent Flyer.

What winning programs have in common

They work with human behaviour, not against it.

Most brands aren’t held back by too few benefits. They’re held back by friction, which shows up in two ways:

  • Participation friction: how easily a member uses the program in the moment.
  • Earn and redemption friction: how easily a member turns participation into reward.

Friction matters because of one core Human Truth™: we are wired to take the path of least effort.

Text graphic: the experience of friction is underpinned by one Human Truth™. We are wired to take the path of least effort.

When brands truly embody and design for this Human Truth™, the result is the formation of habit loops that keep customers engaged, effortlessly.

Flybuys is a masterclass in delivering to cognitive ease and reducing friction at every point of interaction.

Nearly 4/5 Flybuys members actively favour shopping where they can use Flybuys. Nearly three in ten (29%) shop exclusively where they can, and half (50%) are more likely to.

Hand holding a Flybuys card beside the stat: 79% of members favour shopping where they can use Flybuys.

How Flybuys makes it feel effortless

Red Flybuys signs at a checkout with QR codes and the text "Sign up to Flybuys here" and "More value with every scan".

Participation fits how people already shop. Members can scan a physical card, tap a phone wallet pass or open the app, whichever suits them at checkout. Nobody is forced into one method. The program also works across the retailer network, with no separate app for each.

Coles self-serve checkout screen asking shoppers to pay with Coles Pay or scan their Flybuys, with a Skip button.

Redemption is just as simple. Flybuys keeps redemption just as simple. 2,000 points equals $10 off, a flat rate with no tiers to compare and no calculation required. The moment a customer has enough points banked, the discount is prompted automatically at checkout, so redeeming feels as effortless as earning.

Bring these together and Flybuys unlocks something more than convenience: the lack of friction allows consumers to enter into a habit loop, where earning and redeeming happen so automatically that ongoing engagement takes no real effort at all.

Three ways to remove friction from your program

1. Give members multiple ways to participate.

Offer physical cards, digital cards, phone numbers, emails and apps.
Why? With one method, a forgotten card, a flat battery or a slow app becomes a lost opportunity.

2. Make sign-up simple.

Let members join in store, in the moment, in a few minutes.
Why? When joining is split across channels (grab a card in store, then register at home), many members who start never finish.

3. Make redemption quick.

Redeeming should not need multiple confirmations, approvals or delivery delays.
Why? When the effort of redeeming outweighs the value of the reward, such as a gift card posted weeks later, members lose interest fast.

Learn more in The Science of Loyalty 2026 edition

Your members will always take the easiest path. The only question is whether your program is it.

The Science of Loyalty 2026 shows how Australia’s top programs make it the easy path, and where yours might be getting in its own way.

Get your copy today.

Honeycomb Strategy is a behaviourally-led market research agency that turns human complexity into strategic clarity. We combine validated behavioural science methodologies with traditional research tools and AI-enhanced capability to deliver research that predicts behaviour – not just measures perception.

Picture of Renata Freund

Renata Freund

Founder & Director

All wonderful things start with a simple hello.